I dont expect LaPorsha Renae to win, but shes been the star of the season for me. Shes probably had the five best vocals of this season and shes put a big gap between her performances and the ones turned in by Dalton and Trent. Still, I doubt Id put her among my 2. So which Idol singers would make my Top 1. Watch Plongeur Fantastique Online Movies24free more. Funny you and my editors should ask Ive based this list mostly on Idol performance, as in how folks did on the TV show that helped launch their careers. I know that sounds like a no brainer, but Im going to have left off some folks who are regulars on compilations of this sort. Its also a really subjective list. I know that also sounds like a no brainer, but its why somebody like Clay Aiken maybe comes in at 1. Top 1. 0. Clays great. But nobody requested my Top 1. This article needs additional citations for verification. Please help improve this article by adding citations to reliable sources. American Idol Season 10. As American Idol starts coming to a close, heres our countdown of American Idol alums biggest Hot 100 hits ever and the untold stories behind the songs. The biggest and most shocking exclusion here is likely to be Carrie Underwood, unquestionably one of the three most successful Idol contestants. As fine as Carrie was, she was essentially handled the Idol crown in commercials before the season started and she delivered one classic performance. Watch Dead Calm Online Hollywoodreporter on this page. Week to week, Carrie was steadily outperformed on the Idol stage by Bo Bice and hes not in my Top 1. I didnt put Carrie there. I also didnt include Oscar winner Jennifer Hudson, whose Idol tenure was sheer potential, but often nuance free in its execution on the way to an early exit that really wasnt as surprising as we now pretend it was. I regret leaving Phillip Phillips, owner of the best Idol winning name and the best Idol coronation song, out of my Top 1. And Candice Glovers. And boy was I a fan of Crystal Bowersox, but her relative disinterest or the impression of relative disinterest allowed Lee Dewyze to win and thats inexcusable. Read more American Idol All 1. Winners So Far and What Theyre Doing Now.